61
General Discussion / Re: Crystal Palace v Chelsea - D England (VAR M Donohue)
« Last post by rustyref on Mon 26 Jan 2026 19:14 »For completeness, this was the rationale for the 2024 law change that Dermot referred to. Nothing to do with a shot being on target, rather to bring it in line with other DOGSO offences so that players who give away a penalty as a consequence of their arm position aren't sent off.
Non-deliberate handball offences are usually the result of a player attempting to play fairly, so when a penalty kick is awarded for such offences, the same philosophy should apply as for offences (fouls) which are an attempt to play the ball or a challenge for the ball, i.e. DOGSO offences result in a yellow card and SPA offences result in no card. Deliberate handball remains a red-card offence when a penalty kick is awarded, as it is similar to holding, pulling, pushing, no possibility to play the ball etc
Non-deliberate handball offences are usually the result of a player attempting to play fairly, so when a penalty kick is awarded for such offences, the same philosophy should apply as for offences (fouls) which are an attempt to play the ball or a challenge for the ball, i.e. DOGSO offences result in a yellow card and SPA offences result in no card. Deliberate handball remains a red-card offence when a penalty kick is awarded, as it is similar to holding, pulling, pushing, no possibility to play the ball etc

Recent Posts
