It seems that Giles, Silverwood and Thorpe are carrying the can.
Think Silverwood was only carrying out Giles rotation plan, so a shade unlucky, nice chap as Silverwood is i think he got the job to early and they burdened him with too much responsibility.
Root keeps the captaincy, which was expected, there arent too many candidates to replace him.
Asking Stokes would be too much after his season out due personal issues and no one else should be guaranteed their place.
Interesting to see who, if any, miss out on the w indies tour.