76
General Discussion / Re: William Collum - Young Boys v Fradi
« on: Thu 19 Aug 2021 14:21 »
Hi All, Here is my thoughts for what they are worth on the main points.
The tackle Yc sits in the high range of a YC. Ref is correct to give it. HAd Willie C gone Red it would be wrong. Remember that the old adage of orange card is now down grade to a yellow not upgraded.
Pen andRc is spot on.
Disallowed goal is correct based on the footage shown.
Willie C will get ticks for Key decisions but and this is personal opinions... we must be the lowest of the Elite referees.
Even giving the correct decisions he does not look comfortable or inspire confidence.
The tackle Yc sits in the high range of a YC. Ref is correct to give it. HAd Willie C gone Red it would be wrong. Remember that the old adage of orange card is now down grade to a yellow not upgraded.
Pen andRc is spot on.
Disallowed goal is correct based on the footage shown.
Willie C will get ticks for Key decisions but and this is personal opinions... we must be the lowest of the Elite referees.
Even giving the correct decisions he does not look comfortable or inspire confidence.