RateTheRef

It’s a mixed bag of foul detection, agreed that kluivert should have gone, but booked omobamidele for waving an imaginary yellow in same incident. So Rebecca is probably thinking I’m not sending him off because you tell me too. But in any case he should have gone. But made a good call for the Billing sending off described as a hack down the achilles. I think her fitness is ok and I rate her but I just think today her foul detection and issuing misconduct let her down a bit today.

Quote from: thesensibleone on Tue 26 Dec 2023 05:41

Quote from: bmb on Mon 25 Dec 2023 14:02

Quote from: Failed Ref on Mon 25 Dec 2023 10:12

Reported that Forest have received an apology from Webb, and club have asked that Jones no longer officiates any game they are involved in, even as a VAR. Sad state of affairs. What can you do? Mistakes have always been part of the game but now they are highlighted in such a manner to be almost detrimental to the game a a whole.

If I was Howard Webb he would be on every other game of theirs for the foreseeable future. No club has the right to ask for a particular referee to be on their games or not. Perhaps refs can start asking for certain players or managers/coaches not to be included in the squad because they always cause issues? Really dislike clubs thinking they can dictate who does or doesn't referee them. It was an error, a bad one but get over it seriously!

No thanks bmb. As a referee and a Forest supporter I can say this if it happened to any other team and I know Wolves have had it happen quite alot to them they would be saying the same thing. This is Rob Jones 2nd error this season with Forest after the game with manchester united this season that's why Forest have had enough. They are fighting to stay in the league without Rob Jones adding to there problems with his errors.

We've had many bad decisions go against us, penalties that were wrong calls but bizarrely didn't meet the clear and obvious criteria, but never have we asked for a referee not to be on our games though. 1 particular now retired referee who always received praise on here - never once saw him have a good game for us, always big errors, every single game, we had many good reasons to have asked for him to be kept away but rightly never did so. Referee error is just that, they are mere human beings, it's impossible for them to be 100% accurate. Players make more errors in 1 game than referees do across a season and they add up to be the most costly thing for any team. If your team go down, it won't be because of 2 errors by Rob Jones, it will be because of the multitude of missed shots, misplaced passes, poor goalkeeping etc.

Totally agree but I also said they didn't want him adding to there problems

I remember Mark Clattenburg was kept away from Everton for quite awhile and Mike Dean on request  from Arsenal if I'm right in the past it happens all the time not just Nottingham Forest

It was a really bad day, he lost control from the point he blew his whistle for the 2nd booking he gave to boly and there was no coming back from that.

How can you.justify making so many calls like this at the top as there was 8 eyes looking at it on field only 2 had an opinion. What is the point of the other 6 eyes that are suppose to matter being there?

Another 6 eyes are watching in the hub and they couldn't get it right either

Apologies forthcoming I expect from pgmol

Did someone say on here the full audio of a wsl today  or women’s champions league final would be broadcast live

If so which thanks in advance

With the reintroduction of Bobby Madley to the premier league weekend just gone at Brentford i am one glad he is back and this is coming from a referee that is very much disabled but refuses to give in and wants to lead a normal life as possible. Just to give a bit of insight it is very obvious i am disabled and have been from birth and receive abuse on the pitch in the street on a daily basis but you learn to rise above it and be the better person and sometimes come out with quick one liners that shut the abusers up.

I'm not saying what Bobby did acceptable and i was the first one to criticize him when we found out what he did but he is human and has an unbelievable talent for refereeing he was so good on his return at Brentford. Does he not deserve a second chance?

The FA know how to deal with referees at county and pro level but they have not got a foggiest when it comes to players and that is something they lack on the discrimination front in my experience with refereeing so you just to rise above it as i got told DO NOT ISSUE A RED CARD IF YOU HEAR ANYTHING SAID TOWARDS YOU JUST MOVE TO ANOTHER PART OF THE PITCH SO YOU DON'T HEAR IT, AND IGNORE IT. That is how the county fa dealt with my disability from players.

I think everyone who loves football should be involved in football someway mistakes like his he has been punished for now appreciate his talent on the pitch as you have not got that with some SG1/SG2 refs     

I did not watch the game last night but i have seen images of the match and a KMI that changed the game and the two officials in question should have got right at there level and the outcome resulted in a goal which put manchester united on the front foot and nottingham forest awaiting another apology from another referee and linesman.

This time the award of a penalty that was never a penalty and contact was made 2 feet outside the box, you can see clear grass between contact and penalty area and linesman looking right across at it not intervening, i just cannot understand.

Other than this at the teams and officials seemed to have a pretty good night, but again a KMI wrongly awarded penalty gave the momentum to the home team in the final minutes.   

There's no point can't have a view on here

The referee whether female or male, on this occasion being female did her best. We all as referees have difficult games even michael oliver. BUT this is where i have the issue. Players need to grow up and act the age they were meant to be. Would Jon Stones and Jaden Sancho have done what they did if a newbie male (any newbie starting in prem) was in charge. So why make it difficult and act like an idiot and make things more difficult in an already difficult situation for Ms Monzul. Look at the Players actions as well i say they are half to blame.