Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.


Messages - d394829

Pages: [1] 2 3
1
This season reminds me of the 2013-14 season, where Liverpool and Man City tussled for the title, but incorrect refereeing decisions over the course of the season placed Man City top.

does that include the penalty city should have had at anfield in the final few mins of the 3-2?

City shouldn't have had a penalty in that game, but over the course of the season, incorrect decisions hampered Liverpool a lot more than City, which if they would have gone in Liverpool's favour, Liverpool lift the league, not City.

city should have...?

suspect it has more to do with liverpool bottling it once they'd 'won' it but hey ho

If it weren't for incorrect decisions (including a six-point swinger), Liverpool would have had more points on the board and City would have had less.

2
This season reminds me of the 2013-14 season, where Liverpool and Man City tussled for the title, but incorrect refereeing decisions over the course of the season placed Man City top.

does that include the penalty city should have had at anfield in the final few mins of the 3-2?

City shouldn't have had a penalty in that game, but over the course of the season, incorrect decisions hampered Liverpool a lot more than City, which if they would have gone in Liverpool's favour, Liverpool lift the league, not City.

3
This season reminds me of the 2013-14 season, where Liverpool and Man City tussled for the title, but incorrect refereeing decisions over the course of the season placed Man City top.

4
Can anyone explain how Liverpool weren't given a free kick for Lyanco's blatant foul on Jota, which started the build up to the Southampton goal.

5
General Discussion / Re: C PAWSON - The FA Cup Final
« on: Sat 14 May 2022 22:50 »
I agree with all the comments here, great team performance by the officials, if only it was always like this.

6
General Discussion / Re: Jon Moss Aston Villa v Liverpool
« on: Tue 10 May 2022 20:47 »
A mod/admin may as well change the title from "Jon Moss Aston Villa v Liverpool" to "Complete Shambles - Aston Villa v Liverpool". I agree with Comeonref about the erratic foul detection, but lets not forget, not one, but two Aston players standing in offside positions in the build-up to their goal.

7
General Discussion / Re: P TIERNEY - Leeds v Man City
« on: Sun 01 May 2022 19:43 »
I agree about all the comments about Tierney not being good enough, it is also him who's poor decisions have had most of an effect on the title race, I'd say his calls (Jota penalty not given and Rodri Handball Penalty not given) make him more droppable for what Kevin Friend was dropped for.

8
General Discussion / A Taylor - Man City v Liverpool
« on: Mon 11 Apr 2022 06:31 »
Does anybody think that Laporte's challenge on Jota should have been a penalty? When watching the replay, I seen that when Laporte slid in, his foot landed somewhere, then the ball hit his foot just after, which means the ball hits his foot, not him getting the ball.

9
General Discussion / Re: David Coote. Chelsea v Newcastle
« on: Sun 13 Mar 2022 17:05 »
It seems to me that David Coote is refereeing fifty or sixty years too late from what I'm reading.

10
General Discussion / Re: VAR - Brighton V Liverpool
« on: Sat 12 Mar 2022 13:26 »
The sooner that it is considered to be too risky to have Stuart Attwell and Sian Massey-Ellis refereeing matches either in the middle, or via VAR, the better, at least Sian Massey-Ellis is competent when brandishing the offside flag, the numbers board is Stuart Attwell's level, and this is from him having an OK cup final as well.

As Mike Dean, (the card shark), why didn't he consider that even a booking?

11
General Discussion / Re: P TIERNEY - Everton v Man City
« on: Sat 26 Feb 2022 19:40 »
First Spurs v Liverpool, now Everton v Man City, perhaps they can't handle the big games, also, without implying anything, it could be these two officials and their decisions have almost single handedly decided the title race.

12
Seriously, how can things like this be missed?  By both the on field officials and VAR.

https://twitter.com/afcmax22/status/1481387992199704581

Wrestling with his neck, and nothing given.

13
General Discussion / Re: Anthony Taylor Chelsea V Liverpool
« on: Sun 02 Jan 2022 23:49 »
Mane and Mount lucky not to have seen red, apart from that. a well refereed game of football.

14
General Discussion / Re: Goalkeeping Laws
« on: Sun 02 Jan 2022 10:35 »
I thought it was, as each time I've seen a goalkeeper handball outside of the box it has been a red card.

15
General Discussion / Goalkeeping Laws
« on: Sun 02 Jan 2022 09:57 »
Do the goalkeeping laws need changing?

Why is it a mandatory red card for handball outside of the box when actual fouls like

Pickford on Van Dijk

Ederson on Fraser

Ederson on Odegaard

have gone completely unpunished.

I would suggest incidents like the ones above, automatic penalty and a red card (like it is for outfield players) and goalkeeper handball outside the box should be a yellow card.

Pages: [1] 2 3