+-

+-User

Welcome, Guest.
Please login or register.
 
 
 

Login with your social network

Forgot your password?

+-Stats ezBlock

Members
Total Members: 953
Latest: Yorksref
New This Month: 21
New This Week: 3
New Today: 1
Stats
Total Posts: 75100
Total Topics: 5526
Most Online Today: 148
Most Online Ever: 17046
(Mon 29 Mar 2021 19:08)
Users Online
Members: 7
Guests: 90
Total: 97

Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.


Messages - Maltese Falcon

Pages: [1] 2
1
General Discussion / Re: Southampton V Spurs
« on: Tue 04 Jan 2022 15:20 »
And - wherever you draw that line - a toe-nail is one-day going to emerge across it and cause a goal to be scrubbed off.

The line can be 1mm or 1 metre wide - but it is still a line with a binary outcome:  Either offside or not offside.

Unless you want to go down the "Umpire's call" road ??

I would heartily love us to go down the 'Umpire's Call' route and back the judgement of our highly experienced and skilled on field ARs unless there is quick and obvious video evidence that a glaring mistake has been made

2
We can (and should) debate some of the KMDs in today's games.  And IMO the non penalty for Liverpool and the non red card card for Kane were incorrect.

However, let's also recognise that Tierney and team facilitated a tremendous game of football ... and the two dissent YCs and the delaying the restart YC for Liverpool give hope and support to all grassroots officials out there.

3
General Discussion / Re: Promotion 2021
« on: Mon 22 Nov 2021 12:25 »
List of mid season promotions to Panel Select AR (National League / PL2).  Congrats to all concerned

Liam Beames (Glos)
Alan Berrow (Glos)
Alex Bradley (Sussex)
Ashley Clarke (Birmingham)
Jack Clench (Glos)
Tom Cooke (Northants)
Andrew Ellis (Birmingham)
Martyn Fryer (Notts)
Lee Hartley (Lincs)
Tom Holden (Dorset)
Russell Jones (Herts)
Zac Kennard-Kettle (Northumberland)
Peter Lowe (Hants)
Harry Warner (Staffs)
Daniel Woolley (Lincs)

4
Non-League / Re: Professional Reserve Leagues - 2021/22
« on: Fri 17 Sep 2021 18:54 »
Abigail Byrne I believe

5
General Discussion / Re: J VALENZUELA - Brazil v Argentina
« on: Wed 08 Sep 2021 12:32 »
This isn’t the Referee’s problem any more than it would be for a parks Referee when a Sunday League team fields a ringer or a suspended player. The teams submit team sheets and it’s not up to the officials to confirm eligibility to play in the game.

Though, presumably, in the case of the Argentine players, if one of the referees decided that their safety was in question because of the players on the team sheet, then they would be within their rights not to officiate the game?

6
I can, completely reliably, confirm that Mr Jones was taking a well earned rest after his exertions bench side at St Albans the previous day.  He was replaced by the far more aesthetically pleasing Georgia Ball  :)

7
At Level 2B, the referee fee is £75, the Assistant fee £45.  Expenses are 35p per mile

At Level 2A, the referee fee is £120, AR is £60 and 4th Official is £40.  Again, plus 35p per mile

When you consider that the officials are normally out of their houses for approximately 7 hours for one of these games, it's not a level to make you rich!

8
General Discussion / Re: San Marino vs. Gibraltar
« on: Thu 19 Nov 2020 08:23 »
Fair point!  Slightly misworded as I meant to say two OF the most high profile matches (Arsenal v Chelsea and the Midlands derby). :)

9
General Discussion / Re: San Marino vs. Gibraltar
« on: Tue 17 Nov 2020 12:05 »

And yet they can't find three female officials for most of the top English women's matches.

Whilst I don't disagree with the overall sentiment, worth pointing out that in this weekend's WSL matches, all six games were refereed by female officials and in the case of the two most high profile matches, all four officials were female.

I've been fortunate enough to have assisted two of these officials in WSL matches earlier this season and they both acquitted themselves admirably.

Times are changing ... unfortunately slower than would be ideal, despite the extra support now on offer to promising female officials (in my county, two of our three nominations this year for FA Core were female)

edited to fix the quote thingamajigga, bmb.

10
General Discussion / Re: Pyramid Patrol 2020/21
« on: Thu 01 Oct 2020 08:15 »
I am told JCFC that there is one big national pool for all referees at this level so realistically any referee could be appointed anywhere.
In these uncertain times of COVID the finances of these clubs will be stretching thinly
[/quote]

That's not strictly accurate.  Whilst ALL referees at Level 4 and above are "FA" officials and therefore able to take charge of games across the whole country, realistically, L3 and L4 appointments are typically made within around an hour's drive time.  In fact, with separate travel for officials because of COVID protocol, appointments this year are likely to be even more local than this.  That said, for those wishing to officiate further afield, there is always the option of giving a temporary address for a day, weekend or even longer

11
General Discussion / Re: Refeering standards in England
« on: Thu 23 Jul 2020 08:50 »
Reading the above discussion has got me wondering whether there is (or should be) a similar structure in place at National List Level, to that lower down the pyramid ... specifically, from personal experience, at Level 3.

At this Level, if any official has not featured in the Top 40% of the bandings for three consecutive seasons, then they are in the frame for demotion.  This ensures that that those 'scraping by' each year, without showing any indication of the talent to progress upwards, will not be allowed to 'clog up' the system.

It's harsh, but IMO fair

12
General Discussion / Re: Specialist Assistant Referee
« on: Sun 05 Jul 2020 13:36 »
For the first season, he can expect to continue to get the same level of lines as in previous seasons .. most likely that is at Step 3 and Step 4 of the NLS, so Isthmian Premier and Isthmian Div Ones for example.  I would guess he may well be used more on Step 3 than 4, especially if his Observations are good.  The real change, aside from the fact that he will no longer be doing Supply League Middles, is that the opportunity now exists to progress to the higher levels of assisting, in the first instance that would be Step 2 (National League North or South)

13
General Discussion / Re: 20/21 Season - when will we restart?
« on: Sun 07 Jun 2020 06:07 »
The thing for me is the total lack of competition integrity here. How is it fair, and where is the integrity, of increasing substitutions mid way through the season? We're ending with a competition that never started, and that just isn't fair across the board.

What would you think if another club was top of the table, say Man City, for example?

Exactly the same, 1,000%! I've been unwavering in my views that human life is worth way more than a Premier League title, and have been vocal in my thoughts that Liverpool should have been awarded the title long before the stage we're at now. The fact you think I'd be any different if my team we're top of the league is, quite frankly, crass.

Given the extensive testing regime being undertaken, we are obviously past the 'human life' argument ... the EPL matches will be safer than going to the supermarket, park etc.

Which brings us to the competition integrity argument.  On that point, whilst the tweaks to the playing conditions are unhelpful, it still seems way more 'in the spirit of the game' to complete the season on the pitch rather than just 'fill in the gaps' of the unplayed games with some version of PPG?

14
General Discussion / Re: Promotion 2020
« on: Thu 28 May 2020 21:41 »
Referees who have been successful in getting promoted to Panel Select (and therefore working on National League rather than NLS or NLN matches) have been informed and the news is coming out on Twitter etc.  Not seen a full list yet though ... hopefully tomorrow

Here you go!

Steven Annis      Cornwall FA
Conall Bartlett      Sussex FA
Jon Bolland      Surrey FA
Jamie Cann      Durham FA
Alan Cresswell      Berks & Bucks FA
Joshua Crofts      Huntingdonshire FA
Reece Davies        Derbyshire FA
William Davis      Manchester FA
Nick Dunn              Kent FA
Samuel Fudge       Gloucestershire FA
Andrew Gray         Suffolk FA
Farai Hallam         Essex FA
Chris Horsman      Essex FA
Ayrton Hursey      Essex FA
Dan Jarvis              Sheffield & Hallamshire FA
Sean Jenkins        Hampshire FA
Stuart Kane          Cornwall FA
Grzegorz Kornasiewicz   Oxfordshire FA
Steve Lawson       Durham FA
Jacob Lehane        Leicestershire & Rutland FA
Dane Mccarrick           West Riding FA
Marc Meeten         Sussex FA
Adam Nichol         Northumberland FA
Oliver Noonan      Manchester FA
Jamie O'Connor      Derbyshire FA
Jack Oxenham      Surrey FA
Martin Parker      West Riding FA
Steve Parkinson      Berks & Bucks FA
Mark Pond              Essex FA
Jamie Pope      Essex FA
Daniel Robinson      Birmingham FA
Eugene Robinson   Essex FA
Luke Scott                   Northamptonshire FA
Oliver Spender      Gloucestershire FA
Daniel Todd      Berks & Bucks FA
Jake Topp              Manchester FA
Timothy Walker      Derbyshire FA
Richard Watson      Staffordshire FA
Darren Williams      Northumberland FA

15
General Discussion / Re: Promotion 2020
« on: Wed 27 May 2020 16:53 »
Promoted from Level 3 to Level 2B

James Bancroft      Durham FA
Alex Blake              Hampshire FA
Paul Cooper           Durham FA
Michael Crusham   Lancashire FA
Tom Danaher      Hertfordshire FA
Claudio Gavillucci   Cheshire FA
Oliver Mackey      Leicestershire & Rutland FA
Liam Marshall      Lancashire FA
Jon Maskrey      Staffordshire FA
John Mulligan      Cumberland FA
Gareth Myers      West Riding FA
Darren Rogers      Cheshire FA
Greg Rollason           Staffordshire FA
Matthew Scholes   Shropshire FA
Ben Wyatt              Manchester FA

Promoted from 2B to 2A

Tom Bishop   London FA
Sunny Gill      Berks & Bucks FA
Adam Herczeg   Durham FA
Daniel Lamport   Wiltshire FA
Robert Massey-Ellis   Army FA
Jacob Miles   Sussex FA
Scott Simpson   Staffordshire FA
Scott Tallis      Birmingham FA
Rob Whitton   Essex FA


Pages: [1] 2