1
General Discussion / Re: Halil Umut Meler : Liverpool vs Atalanta
« on: Fri 12 Apr 2024 02:47 »
Very good game, I can’t think of a single conversation starting decision, everything was spot on
|
This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to. 1
General Discussion / Re: Halil Umut Meler : Liverpool vs Atalanta« on: Fri 12 Apr 2024 02:47 »
Very good game, I can’t think of a single conversation starting decision, everything was spot on
2
General Discussion / Re: Tim Robinson: Leeds v Sunderland« on: Wed 10 Apr 2024 01:07 »
Seems like people here have never heard of rush goalie.
Definitely got away with one there immediately got my phone to see a replay at the game, didn’t think he had a good game at all but as a fan I can’t complain 😀 3
General Discussion / Re: Anthony Taylor- United v Liverpool« on: Sun 07 Apr 2024 15:49 »
What does Bruno fernandez have to do to get booked for dissent?
4
General Discussion / Re: John Brooks: BHA v Arsenal« on: Sat 06 Apr 2024 23:17 »
I think it's a clear penalty but inconsistent with other use of var, he's played the ball and they've both entered the same space, Lamptey maybe should have just kicked him in the chest instead and they'd have called it a coming together no penalty
5
General Discussion / Re: Paul Tierney: Crystal Palace v Manchester City (Stuart Attwell on VAR)« on: Sat 06 Apr 2024 16:03 »Stills are very deceptive and prove absolutely nothing. In their defence it looks like the link had a clip but removed Should never be a penalty but city were awarded a very similar penalty earlier in the season against man utd by var so where is the consistency https://twitter.com/MKTIRB/status/1776605584713806041?s=19 https://twitter.com/MKTIRB/status/1776605584713806041?s=19 6
General Discussion / Re: Jarred gillett- Chelsea v Utd« on: Thu 04 Apr 2024 22:16 »
Very slow by Coote to confirm that penalty not too sure what he was looking at
Overall while some niggly complaints from me regarding some yellow cards a very good game for gillet 7
General Discussion / Re: Jarred gillett- Chelsea v Utd« on: Thu 04 Apr 2024 22:11 »Staggered Antony wasn’t at least booked in the first half for his foul mouth rant at the linesman. Especially after earlier in the season when I was told he is very hard on dissent, must have a different approach here 8
General Discussion / Re: Jarred gillett- Chelsea v Utd« on: Thu 04 Apr 2024 21:30 »
Not sure how Maguire escaped a card just there (around 52:00) ball flicked over him and he takes the attacker out stopping a promising attack
9
General Discussion / Re: Drone referees« on: Mon 01 Apr 2024 13:09 »
Sounds similar to var they will need some piloting and human involved, var for everything will solve all complaints I’m very happy with this
10
General Discussion / Re: A Taylor - Man City V Arsenal« on: Sun 31 Mar 2024 18:05 »
He is definitely playing a part in putting me to sleep (best praise I can give a referee but not the 2 teams playing)
11
General Discussion / Re: Newcastle v West Ham - Rob Jones« on: Sun 31 Mar 2024 18:03 »Some people here (perhaps with some red and white tinted glasses) seem to be missing some fundamental points here. Should I call it Coote working to the best of his ability, unfortunately for him that is lacking? Going back to my point of mentioning fans of other teams saying it’s not a foul that was in part of me being questioned because of the team I support, maybe we should question if the defence from certain people here is simply because of their support for referees, you mentioned other forums if I go to a teams forum they defend their team no matter what here it’s the referees defended no matter their mistakes. Also you mentioned the show who employ Newcastles biggest fan didn’t discuss their favourable decisions shocking. At the very least as shown by the discussion here with others disagreeing with you the only thing clear and obvious is VAR being misused 12
General Discussion / Re: D COOTE - Liverpool v Brighton« on: Sun 31 Mar 2024 15:48 »
The Coote experience just not good enough, I'm surprised he booked Van Hecke he got into the position in front of nunez and nunez's leg went into him clear foul by nunez based on his decision yesterday
13
General Discussion / Re: Newcastle v West Ham - Rob Jones« on: Sun 31 Mar 2024 15:46 »Some people here (perhaps with some red and white tinted glasses) seem to be missing some fundamental points here. Plenty of people here seem to know the decision was bs, according to var you're entitled to challenge for a ball on the opponents chest but not a ball you have under full control in case a player tries to initiate contact and succeeds 14
General Discussion / Re: Newcastle v West Ham - Rob Jones« on: Sun 31 Mar 2024 12:16 »Some people here (perhaps with some red and white tinted glasses) seem to be missing some fundamental points here. Talk about arrogance, if a defender challenges an opponent with no intention of playing the ball just cause contact and impede the opponent how can it not be a free kick. 15
General Discussion / Re: Simon Hooper : Brentford vs Man Utd« on: Sun 31 Mar 2024 03:18 »
Missed the first 30 minutes of the 2nd half but from what I did see everything seemed pretty great
|