1
General Discussion / Re: Paul Tierney - Chelsea vs Newcastle
« on: Sun 15 Mar 2026 08:58 »
Bringing the game into disrepute,do you remember when that was a thing?!!!

|
This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to. 1
General Discussion / Re: Paul Tierney - Chelsea vs Newcastle« on: Sun 15 Mar 2026 08:58 »
Bringing the game into disrepute,do you remember when that was a thing?!!!
2
General Discussion / Re: M Guida- Newcastle v Barcalona« on: Tue 10 Mar 2026 21:05 »
Dutch ref in the Spurs game gave free kick leading to 4th goal,Sarr not within a foot of the player who went down as though shot,AR 2 metres away
3
General Discussion / Re: P Bankes- Newcastle v Man Utd« on: Thu 05 Mar 2026 08:35 »
Didn’t give Bruno YC for his petulant display of dissent including the words Fu*k off during added on time
4
General Discussion / Re: Newcastle v Chelsea - Andy Madley (VAR Peter Bankes)« on: Thu 01 Jan 2026 03:10 »
What gives this panel more creadence than anyone else’s opinion?
5
General Discussion / Re: J BROOKS - Spurs v Liverpool« on: Mon 22 Dec 2025 06:53 »
Having watched the whole match back I would say the following.
Gould detection throughout the match was inconsistent. Penalised Spence for a foul on Bradley when it appeared that Bradley just lost his footing,other times letting pulling go Simons Red Card seemed correct although not as bad as some people are saying,fleeting contact with the studs on the calf,no contact on the Achilles as other posters have said. Clear 2 handed push into Romeros’ back who’s feet were off the ground so pushed under the ball No excuse for the reaction and yellow card that followed. 2nd yellow,mindless from Romero Alleged grab off the throat by Richalison,although a stupid thing to do,it was the back of the neck!! 9 minutes of added time,a goal,an injury to Frimpong,2 Subs,Only 1 added minute! Overall not a good showing from Brooks 6
General Discussion / Re: Andrew kitchen- Man Utd v West Ham« on: Thu 04 Dec 2025 20:15 »
Could have been YC to Amad for simulation
7
General Discussion / Re: Newcastle v Tottenham - Thomas Bramall (VAR Paul Tierney)« on: Wed 03 Dec 2025 10:36 »
I feel the holding was 50/50 and then Burn used is body weight to push Bentancur to the ground
8
General Discussion / Re: C KAVANAGH - Man City v Liverpool« on: Sun 16 Nov 2025 14:00 »
Sorry fat finger syndrome,meant to agree
9
General Discussion / Re: C KAVANAGH - Man City v Liverpool« on: Sun 09 Nov 2025 17:19 »
As a subjective decision should it not be OFR?
10
General Discussion / Re: Craig Pawson - Sunderland v Arsenal« on: Sat 08 Nov 2025 20:23 »
But when is Arteta going to be stopped from running so close to the pitch?
11
General Discussion / Re: Craig Pawson : Everton vs Tottenham« on: Sun 26 Oct 2025 19:32 »
Refreshing to hear David Moues agreed withe decision to disallow the goal
12
General Discussion / Re: Craig Pawson : Everton vs Tottenham« on: Sun 26 Oct 2025 17:34 »
The offside is factual,subjective if interfering,it was right to send CP to the screen to make his own mind up
13
General Discussion / Re: C PAWSON - Brentford v Man U« on: Sat 27 Sep 2025 14:28 »
No surprise from Andy Madley after his performance at Spurs
14
General Discussion / Re: Andrew Madley - Tottenham vs Doncaster (EPL Cup)« on: Thu 25 Sep 2025 08:02 »
I think AM may have realised he’d made an error so was saying high foot, an then didn’t indicate indirect free kick
15
General Discussion / Re: Andrew Madley - Tottenham vs Doncaster (EPL Cup)« on: Wed 24 Sep 2025 21:24 »
Only watched the second half but he seems all over the place with foul detection
If Danso challenge is a foul,I don’t think it was,it’s got to be a card |