1
General Discussion / Re: C PAWSON - Arsenal v Man U
« on: Sun 25 Jan 2026 20:40 »
If we're looking at possible but spurious reasons to disallow a goal Merino nudged United keeper under the ball for the second goal

|
This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to. 1
General Discussion / Re: C PAWSON - Arsenal v Man U« on: Sun 25 Jan 2026 20:40 »
If we're looking at possible but spurious reasons to disallow a goal Merino nudged United keeper under the ball for the second goal
2
General Discussion / Re: Worst performance ever« on: Fri 16 Jan 2026 22:56 »
You should really watch some of the National League Referee performances over the past decade if you're looking for worst ever performances
3
General Discussion / Re: Newcastle vs City- Kavanagh/Attwell« on: Wed 14 Jan 2026 20:35 »
How many defending players were between Haaland and the Goal Line?
4
General Discussion / Re: Newcastle vs City- Kavanagh/Attwell« on: Wed 14 Jan 2026 09:15 »
The only non contentious element of this imo was the Offside
Both Haaland and Thiaw were behind the GK, in fact, nobody was closer to the Goal Line than the two of them. Therefore the Offside was factually correct. As has been said the interference element is subjective and the OFR could / should have been recommended much quicker without the need for all the farting about With lines etc. 5
General Discussion / Re: Anthony Taylor - Arsenal v Liverpool« on: Fri 09 Jan 2026 09:16 »
I would venture to suggest that had he issued a Red Card it would have been appealed and rescinded.
From a personal perspective AT was probably as disgusted as anyone but had to remain professional and deal with what he could how he could 6
General Discussion / Re: Anthony Taylor - Arsenal v Liverpool« on: Thu 08 Jan 2026 21:44 »
Finally someone has cautioned Arteta for his expeditions outside his Technical Area
7
General Discussion / Re: Tom Kirk - Everton v Wolves« on: Thu 08 Jan 2026 21:06 »
It is, using current guidelines and interpretation Violent Conduct.
Sorry, I know this doesn't answer your precise question 8
EFL League 1, 2 & National League Prem / Re: Sat 3rd & Sun 4th JAN 2026« on: Sun 04 Jan 2026 11:37 »
Was a bit of a catastrophe really
The game was declared on at two different points, supporters were admitted, players warmed up. At 2.45 the turnstiles were closed and at 2.52 by my watch, the postponement was announced. I believe it was his first game at this level so the pressure must have been greater than usual so I have a degree of sympathy but, it wasn't really what anyone would have wanted. Clearly I don't know definitively what happened but I'd have thought / hoped that he may have received guidance from his ARs or other people with him which appears not to be the case 9
General Discussion / Re: Keith Hackett.........AGAIN !!!!!« on: Tue 30 Dec 2025 18:01 »
Would it be acceptable to say that during his Active days Mr Hackett could have justifiably been referred to as a "trundler"
If not then my apologies, please delete 10
General Discussion / Re: On field discipline« on: Tue 30 Dec 2025 17:56 »
Apologies if I'm repeating a comment here.
What strikes me as odd with some of these on field discipline issues (surrounding referees, not retreating immediately at FKs, Foul throws etc) is that these issues seem possibly less prevalent at grass roots level, taking the game as a whole. Referees seem to move players, away, back etc quite a bit quicker. I know we're dealing with an entirely different level of game and scrutiny but shifting players immediately does seem to help control 11
General Discussion / Re: Ref Watch: 27/10/25« on: Mon 29 Dec 2025 21:17 »
He does however seem to tick the most important box for SKY.
He comes from the London area. 12
General Discussion / Re: Ref Watch: 27/10/25« on: Mon 29 Dec 2025 19:44 »
He does however seem to tick the most important box for SKY.
He comes from the London area. 13
General Discussion / Re: 2026 Officiating Predictions« on: Sun 28 Dec 2025 11:53 »
Ms Burgin is Refereeing at Altrincham on Tuesday evening
14
General Discussion / Re: Altrincham FC v Rochdale - Peter Wright« on: Sat 20 Dec 2025 09:18 »
Whilst obviously respecting the views of a fellow contributor, I must disagree with a couple of your points.
Re your 2nd goal, I was on my way back from the Gents and your player was literally standing on the dead ball line. He was in advance even of the AR and his cross went back away from the line. I know that as I was dead in line The first penalty claim, I will give you as subjective. The second was an extremely obvious shirt pull described by Mr Wright as yes a shirt pull but not hard enough to warrant a penalty I hope you have an enjoyable break and wish you Seasons Greetings 15
General Discussion / Altrincham FC v Rochdale - Peter Wright« on: Fri 19 Dec 2025 23:00 »
First time I've seen this guy for a good while.
I recall, I think, that he was considered promising before (correct me if I'm wrong) dropping off the radar as it were due to injury? We accept that we aren't necessarily going to get the greatest Officials every week, given the level we operate at BUT this evening was one of the most concerning performances I've seen in a while. Supporters around me asserted that they were cheating. They weren't, IMO they were just inept. Firstly don't think that I'm suggesting that we deserved anything out of tonight other than a defeat so this isn't any sort of "what if" post. That being said, and we have seen some substandard performances over the years, tonight's Officiating Team was as poor as I can recall for many a moon. Foul detection was at best haphazard. How there was only one Yellow Card is a mystery. We could (should, but I'm being generous) have had a Penalty in each half. From a laws of the game perspective, the second Rochdale goal was troubling. The guy putting the cross in appeared to receive the ball from a Team Mate whilst standing on the dead ball line. Therefore he SHOULD have been adjudged offside. Corners were awarded to both sides, seemingly based on who shouted loudest. Play was stopped for sometimes no apparent reason. Free Kicks had to be taken from a precise blade of grass, but we're the taken 5 metres away. As I say, we were well beaten so please don't think I'm trying to suggest that we ought to have got anything out of the game |