The DRS decision by Saikat demonstrated really bad communication and uncertainty. He gave absolutely no confidence to those watching.
He had taken almost 5 minutes to make that decision which indicated there is enough doubt to give the batsman out.He should have stick to the on field not out decision. But I remember former elite panel umpire Marais Erasmus once said RTS sometimes detect edges after some frames unlike ultraedgde.So in that sense he might have got it right.
The DRS decision by Saikat demonstrated really bad communication and uncertainty. He gave absolutely no confidence to those watching.