+-

+-User
Welcome, Guest.
Please login or register.
 
 
 

Login with your social network

Forgot your password?

+-Stats ezBlock
Members
Total Members: 1361
Latest: Bob Edwardson
New This Month: 7
New This Week: 1
New Today: 0
Stats
Total Posts: 100051
Total Topics: 7379
Most Online Today: 114
Most Online Ever: 35185
(Sat 14 Feb 2026 10:07)
Users Online
Members: 0
Guests: 27
Total: 27

Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.


Messages - NoComment1105

Pages: [1] 2
1
General Discussion / Re: Referee Manager Game
« on: Wed 18 Mar 2026 21:28 »
Couldn't find anyone who suggested this, but maybe more fine grained filtering on the match assignment page? filter by gameweek, filter by team, maybe even filter be referee or var? Loving it far, can't wait to see more!

EDIT: Also maybe the assign screen stops you from appointing a referee twice in the same matchweek as main referee, just for realism purposes

EDIT 2: Also maybe their current merrit table position when you go to select the referee/var. might not be necessary once the saving thing has been figured out because it'll be easier to switch, but just a suggestion

2
General Discussion / Re: Stoke v Ipswich - Tom Kirk
« on: Tue 10 Mar 2026 22:04 »
Personally disagree with the penalty decision, not certain who does more of the pulling, Cajuste or Kipre, but either way, play stupid games, win stupid prizes. Pulling someone in the box is certainly a stupid game

3
General Discussion / Re: P Bankes- Newcastle v Man Utd
« on: Thu 05 Mar 2026 15:34 »
Quote from: ajb95 on Thu 05 Mar 2026 15:30
Thoughts on burn v shaw incident. For me he looks at where Shaw is and there’s a deliberate movement of the elbow into the face. How is that not a red card?

I did consider an RC when it happened but I think the fact that Shaw is basically hugging him, he never looks at him makes me say no RC. I think he's just trying to shake him off

4
General Discussion / Re: P Bankes- Newcastle v Man Utd
« on: Wed 04 Mar 2026 21:16 »
That was certainly an exciting end to the first half.a shame to see the officials booed off, considering I think every big decision was correct. I would agree that play on on the Ramsey penalty shout, but I understand why it was given especially if Antrobus gave the input. Hopefully the second half is just as good from the team

5
General Discussion / Re: P Bankes- Newcastle v Man Utd
« on: Wed 04 Mar 2026 20:57 »
I don't know from the broadcast if his back was turned of not, but his assistants should be yelling him straight away, I'd want mine to do so.

6
General Discussion / Re: tottenham v arsenal - peter bankes (VAR: darren england)
« on: Sun 22 Feb 2026 17:47 »
Neville certainly needs to get over himself. Saying "it's a disgrace" is frankly ridiculous. However, why didn't they look to rectify the second issue during the half time break?

7
General Discussion / Re: Thomas Bramall - Coventry City vs Middlesbrough
« on: Mon 16 Feb 2026 21:12 »
I do think he unfortunately made a mistake with Sakamoto which has only riled this gentleman up more creating more disgruntled feelings towards referees. Something that isn't needed after this weekends unfortunate events

8
General Discussion / Re: Thomas Bramall - Coventry City vs Middlesbrough
« on: Mon 16 Feb 2026 20:52 »
Goodness me the commentators on ITV are chatting some absolute nonsense, something about "post game yellow card reviews because refs are too yellow happy" 🤨🙄

Regardless I think Thomas Bramall has been excellent so far in what has been a challenging first half, that he's handled well. Hoping for more in the second half

9
Select Group - Premier League / Re: Sat 21st - Mon 23rd Feb 2026
« on: Mon 16 Feb 2026 16:07 »
Burnley used in another trial game for Lewis Smith xD and an interesting game at the bottom for Tom Kirk, looks like they havent shot him down for the double dissent cautions. Very excited to see how he gets on!

10
General Discussion / Re: J BROOKS - Man U v Fulham
« on: Tue 03 Feb 2026 13:59 »
Quote from: Ref Fan on Tue 03 Feb 2026 13:56
Just curious about the penalty awarded to Fulham for the foul by Maguire.  My initial reaction was that the contact from the challenge was after the Fulham player got his shot away.  Was this the case?  If it was, I thought there was a view expressed a while back on here, after an incident when Foden was taken out after a shot, that referees rarely give penalties in those situations or take disciplinary action. Maybe the discussion then was more about whether the late challenge on Foden amounted to SFP.  Sorry my memory is a bit vague on this.

I also noticed the same thing but it didn't seem to have been brought up here. Maybe the guidance that penalties shouldn't be given after a shot was taken as been removed? Eitherway I agree with the decision to award the penalty.

11
Select Group - Premier League / Re: Fri 6th - Thu 12th Feb 2026
« on: Mon 02 Feb 2026 16:13 »
Farai Hallam out again in the Premier League so soon! Clearly sticking with his original decision went down well! Very much looking forward to seeing him again

12
General Discussion / Re: Villa-Brentford. Tim Robinson (VAR Tierney)
« on: Sun 01 Feb 2026 23:27 »
Having just watched the highlights on MOTD I think that this whole situation lacks a "smoking gun angle" (to steal the phrase on MLS Instant replay) that tells you for 100% it's out. From the angles shown however, I'm confident it was actually out of play and that APP had not ended. However, there is no chance VAR should be saying it was factually out of play, Robinson should've been sent to the monitor at least, but preferably not at all without the smoking gun angle

13
General Discussion / Re: Sheffield Utd v Ipswich Town - Tom Nield
« on: Sat 24 Jan 2026 16:06 »
Definitely agree with you TA_Ref. I'd forgotten about that moment, I didn't think free kick out but I didn't think penalty. They'd both been spoken too so the eyes were definitely on anything.

Hopefully the lid stays on in the second half and we see some good football

14
General Discussion / Re: Sheffield Utd v Ipswich Town - Tom Nield
« on: Sat 24 Jan 2026 15:53 »
More silliness at the halftime whistle. Both teams just seem to want to wind each other up rather than play football Ipswich. Ipswich looks half a yard off the pace compared to Sheffield United.

Good caution after playing advantage for furlong in the 45th minute.

15
General Discussion / Sheffield Utd v Ipswich Town - Tom Nield
« on: Sat 24 Jan 2026 15:48 »
Seems to be a very good half so far from a referee I've not come across before. Looking to let the game flow where he can but there's some helpings of silliness from both sides,

Only thought is he appears to play advantage for the Sheffield Utd goal, which on first viewing looked to be DOGSO outside the box, yet no caution was issue to Matusiwa? Missed the replay so maybe it was inside the box, definitely an attempt for the ball so if that's the case good call.

Yellow for Walton for starting something silly after the goal spot on and Wilder in the book for trying to wind up the Ipswich bench.

Excellent no penalty call for Sheffield Utd on 42 minutes.

More of the same for the second half

Pages: [1] 2