RateTheRef

General Refereeing => General Discussion => Topic started by: jacksback on Sun 09 Oct 2022 22:56

Title: Lookman booked for glasses celebration
Post by: jacksback on Sun 09 Oct 2022 22:56
Anyone have an explanation for this one? Danielle Doveri refereeing.

https://twitter.com/btsportfootball/status/1579224524968841216?s=20&t=z0ARjezB06EPVN9eTrWzgA
Title: Re: Lookman booked for glasses celebration
Post by: Whistleblower on Sun 09 Oct 2022 23:04
It's very hard to see what he actually does. I suspect the referee, not knowing it's a regular rite of celebration for the player, has misinterpreted the gesture as a piece of dissent. Sometimes players make the glasses sign to indicate to the referee that he/she needs to wear glasses because their eyesight must be defective as they are missing so much. Perhaps that is the explanation.
Title: Re: Lookman booked for glasses celebration
Post by: bmb on Mon 10 Oct 2022 00:04
It's very hard to see what he actually does. I suspect the referee, not knowing it's a regular rite of celebration for the player, has misinterpreted the gesture as a piece of dissent. Sometimes players make the glasses sign to indicate to the referee that he/she needs to wear glasses because their eyesight must be defective as they are missing so much. Perhaps that is the explanation.

Seems the most logical explanation to me, WB.
Title: Re: Lookman booked for glasses celebration
Post by: Microscopist on Mon 10 Oct 2022 12:16
It's very hard to see what he actually does. I suspect the referee, not knowing it's a regular rite of celebration for the player, has misinterpreted the gesture as a piece of dissent. Sometimes players make the glasses sign to indicate to the referee that he/she needs to wear glasses because their eyesight must be defective as they are missing so much. Perhaps that is the explanation.

Seems the most logical explanation to me, WB.
Though the chain of logic in the circumstances that he had just scored seems a bit convoluted; unless of course he had previously had a significant decision go, wrongly in his eyes, against him.
Title: Re: Lookman booked for glasses celebration
Post by: Whistleblower on Mon 10 Oct 2022 13:11
It's very hard to see what he actually does. I suspect the referee, not knowing it's a regular rite of celebration for the player, has misinterpreted the gesture as a piece of dissent. Sometimes players make the glasses sign to indicate to the referee that he/she needs to wear glasses because their eyesight must be defective as they are missing so much. Perhaps that is the explanation.

Seems the most logical explanation to me, WB.
Though the chain of logic in the circumstances that he had just scored seems a bit convoluted; unless of course he had previously had a significant decision go, wrongly in his eyes, against him.

I don't think anyone was accusing the referee of being logical !
Title: Re: Lookman booked for glasses celebration
Post by: Microscopist on Tue 11 Oct 2022 09:16
It's very hard to see what he actually does. I suspect the referee, not knowing it's a regular rite of celebration for the player, has misinterpreted the gesture as a piece of dissent. Sometimes players make the glasses sign to indicate to the referee that he/she needs to wear glasses because their eyesight must be defective as they are missing so much. Perhaps that is the explanation.

Seems the most logical explanation to me, WB.
Though the chain of logic in the circumstances that he had just scored seems a bit convoluted; unless of course he had previously had a significant decision go, wrongly in his eyes, against him.

I don't think anyone was accusing the referee of being logical !
Guess I asked for that!  Though I don't think I could ever be accused of assuming that referees thought logically
Title: Re: Lookman booked for glasses celebration
Post by: jad on Tue 11 Oct 2022 13:32
According to the report I read in the Italian press the caution was because the referee interpreted the gesture as a provocation aimed at the opposing supporters.