RateTheRef
General Refereeing => General Discussion => Topic started by: takethejag on Sun 11 Nov 2018 15:37
-
I would expect Tierney to be 'marked down' after this, two clear mistakes in law for me and another two potentially serious errors.
- Fulham's disallowed goal for offside was potentially an error by the AR, very, very difficult call to make and why VAR would be helpful
- Liverpool's quick restart with a rolling ball, leading to their goal was a clear mistake and they should've been made to retake it
- Gomez cynical pull-back on Mitrovic was a nailed on YC everyday, it has to be a YC, doesn't it?
- Chambers tackle on Salah should have been a RC for SFP. Both feet were momentarily off the floor/out of control.
-
Some real dross this afternoon at Anfield, most notably the disallowed Mitrovic goal....
As my learn'd fellow fan pointed out, other decisions were clearly wrong, and for a FIFA official to get these fairly routine decisions wrong is not good.
-
Some real dross this afternoon at Anfield, most notably the disallowed Mitrovic goal....
As my learn'd fellow fan pointed out, other decisions were clearly wrong, and for a FIFA official to get these fairly routine decisions wrong is not good.
I think you're overusing the word dross - the offside goal was a very, very tight decision.
-
Some real dross this afternoon at Anfield, most notably the disallowed Mitrovic goal....
As my learn'd fellow fan pointed out, other decisions were clearly wrong, and for a FIFA official to get these fairly routine decisions wrong is not good.
I think you're overusing the word dross - the offside goal was a very, very tight decision.
The dross comment was aimed at the overall performance not just the one major talking point..
-
Some real dross this afternoon at Anfield, most notably the disallowed Mitrovic goal....
As my learn'd fellow fan pointed out, other decisions were clearly wrong, and for a FIFA official to get these fairly routine decisions wrong is not good.
Well off side decision was verytight but as shown on MOTD was correct. would be nice if some of you guys could recognise when you got it wrong and officials had a good day . hope you can be a bit more gracious in future when proven to be wrong