RateTheRef

A simple decision - No 6. slow to retrieve the ball, then rolling down the line. Defo - delay of game....

The player who was sent for timewasting really didn't do anything wrong, it was his mate. A poor decision especially for a second YC.
The send off of the keeper had terrible mechanics about it. I would say that the AR was tipped him off, and if that is the case it is poor from the referee as that part of the field is really his. I would say and I realise I only say a 6 min clip but that the referee lacked presence and authority. THis referee can add a lot to his game.

Quote from: lincs22 on Thu 11 Aug 2022 13:35

A simple decision - No 6. slow to retrieve the ball, then rolling down the line. Defo - delay of game....

Looks like several of us are all agreed that no.6 should have been cautioned rather than no.3. A mistake by Mr. Cartmel I would say. Just proves that all Refs are human!

Second yellow card and subsequent one match suspension has quite rightly been rescinded. On grounds of mistaken identity….. hmmm yeah right.

It as to be mistaken identity, you cant appeal a caution on any other grounds, so they cant give any other reason for it being rescinded.

Quote from: Carter on Sun 14 Aug 2022 11:05

It as to be mistaken identity, you cant appeal a caution on any other grounds, so they cant give any other reason for it being rescinded.

If a club is appealing on the grounds of mistaken identity, do they have to identify the correct culprit to that the sanction can be reallocated to their record?  Or does the caution simply disappear into the ether?