Looks a definite red to me. Offiside at end looks incorrect from the angle we have. If it was it was incredibly tight. As for Ross Joyce - Oh dear, like yourself cringe when he is appointed at Swindon Town - suffered badly in the play off semi last season. How he got the game one has to wonder. While on about poor refs have a look at the penalty decision by Paul Howard on Saturday Swindon v Gillingham. Ball clearly hits Swindon defender in face - had to have a bloody nose treated. Howard gives a penalty.